Morning in Arizona

Arizona: Open for Business

Click on the Title to read the full post.

[Fill in Name of Government Program] Would Have Worked Had the Right Person Been Running It

Posted by on | July 19, 2017 | Comments Off

I have disputed the meme in the post’s title on many occasions.  For example:

  • No person running any government agency has access to the same information that millions of individuals might have in making decisions for themselves
  • No person running any government agency can create an optimal solution, because millions of citizens all have different values and make different tradeoffs, so an optimum for one is not going to be an optimum for many others
  • No person running any government agency has the right incentives to make good decisions.  They will always optimize for increasing the size and scope of their organization and signaling virtue over actually being virtuous.

But researchers have found yet another reason:  power causes brain damage

A spate of recent articles corroborate what I already suspected, that holding elected office is the neurological equivalent of getting kicked in the head by a donkey.

“Subjects under the influence of power,” Dacher Keltner, a professor atUniversity of California, Berkeleyfound, “acted as if they had suffered a traumatic brain injury—becoming more impulsive, less risk-aware, and, crucially, less adept at seeing things from other people’s point of view.”

In other words, power turns people into sociopaths.

This isn’t a huge surprise to the vast majority of us who rant about power on election day and every day afterward. Republicans and Democrats want power and scramble for it, like a football. Classical liberals see power more like Frodo’s ring—a corrupting influence better chucked into a volcano. In light of recent studies we ought to consider it a bit more like a concussion.

Keltner, brought into the public spotlight through a recent piece in The Atlantic, likens the accruing of power to actual brain trauma: ”My own research has found that people with power tend to behave like patients who have damaged their brain’s orbitofrontal lobes (the region of the frontal lobes right behind the eye sockets), a condition that seems to cause overly impulsive and insensitive behavior. Thus the experience of power might be thought of as having someone open up your skull and take out that part of your brain so critical to empathy and socially-appropriate behavior.”

 [Fill in Name of Government Program] Would Have Worked Had the Right Person Been Running It  [Fill in Name of Government Program] Would Have Worked Had the Right Person Been Running It  [Fill in Name of Government Program] Would Have Worked Had the Right Person Been Running It

 [Fill in Name of Government Program] Would Have Worked Had the Right Person Been Running It

share save 171 16 [Fill in Name of Government Program] Would Have Worked Had the Right Person Been Running It

Comments

Comments are closed.