Morning in Arizona

Arizona: Open for Business

Click on the Title to read the full post.

The Problem With Social Justice Today — Dividing Rather than Unifying

Posted by on | March 20, 2018 | Comments Off

This article about pronouns on campus embodies all that is wrong with social justice warriors today, but perhaps not for the reason you might guess.

I personally have no particular problem if you want to identify as a male or a female or gender 6 or a zebra.  But here is the real problem:  When I write about you, I don’t know how you self-identify.  And when I write about a random hypothetical person, gender is effectively meaningless.  I want one simple third person pronoun that can be applied to everyone.  I currently use “they” even for the singular, rather than the more awkward “he or she” or just picking a random one each time, though this usage is still controversial.  I don’t care what the damn word is, just let’s agree on one.   The shift in the 1970′s from using Mrs. and Miss to just using Ms. was awesome — if you have ever struggled with trying to guess gender from a name like “pat”, think about what a pain in the butt it was to try to guess marital status before addressing someone.   The only thing that would be an improvement would be to just go to M. for everyone, male or female.

But the proposal in the article has, at my count, 11 different third-person pronouns.  Ack.  This is going in exactly the wrong direction.  It is the same thing that social justice warriors have done on race.  Twenty years ago, perhaps even 10, most everyone would have agreed the ideal goal was to have post-racial or race-blind society.   Sure, celebrate your ethnicity and cultural uniqueness, but when dealing with each other we should think of each other first and second and third as humans, with race being as relevant to how we react to people as hair color.   But of course we have gone in the opposite directly, with Progressives actually arguing for more and more separation and barriers between the races.  So now we are doing the same thing on gender.

The whole point of the pronoun things seems to be not to get us to some sort of harmony but just the opposite, to create new opportunities to shame and abuse people.  After all, if we launch tidal waves of outrage at people for picking the wrong pronoun out of two choices, imagine how much vitriol we can vent with 11 choices to get wrong.

 The Problem With Social Justice Today    Dividing Rather than Unifying  The Problem With Social Justice Today    Dividing Rather than Unifying  The Problem With Social Justice Today    Dividing Rather than Unifying

 The Problem With Social Justice Today    Dividing Rather than Unifying

share save 171 16 The Problem With Social Justice Today    Dividing Rather than Unifying

Comments

Comments are closed.